I just finished uncharted3 and I have to say I wish there was a bit more detail in the story about the main characters relationship. They sort of hinted that drake and elena were married but didn't give a time frame until the very last scene (which felt short by the way). If all 3 games fit inside a 4 year time line then he and Elena couldn't have been married over a year or something. Therese a line about her still wearing the ring, never mind we meet up with her half way around the world. Anyway spoiler alert.....they get back together in the end without any real resolution or acknowledgement of whatever drove them apart... Sure adventure was hinted to be the problem, but again no specifics.
I think I'm no longer your average gamer, but if games are 60 dollars they aren't really for kids anymore...and with this how cinematic they are getting....I want a story, not just waves of bad guys to beat up/shoot at.
There was something special about the second game that this installment doesn't have, i haven't put my finger on it yet, but the pacing of this one felt faster and I think overall it didn't have as many character set pieces as it did action sequences.
Maybe my favorite section in a game ever was a two level part of uncharted 2 where there is no combat and almost no dialog. The main character is in a mountain village and doesn't speak the language. It felt like in was with the character experiencing it as it happened. it was scripted but inventive and genuine. this game didn't have a section like it. The puzzles were easier to solve and not as time consuming. It was of they sat down and decided to downplay y favorite parts in favor of big Hollywood action scene type moments.
So after finishing I started watching the featurettes and the main designer said they write the story as the my build levels and on occasion they have tech they need to use and they write story around it vs just telling a story and building that world. I'm guessing that was also true for uncharted 2, but he difference is that in uncharted 3 it felt that way.
Anyway, maybe more on this tomorrow.
Kb